Thursday, 13 March 2014

News Summary of Collaboration and Shared Services from 12 March 2014



There has been plenty about housing in this week’s shared service and collaboration news…

Last year, in Shared Service Architecture Magazine, Manny Gatt (our MD) wrote about the need for Housing Associations to develop the collaborative leadership skills of their staff, not to share services with each other, but to work effectively in the vacuum left by the reduction in services from local authorities and others.

Manny was not writing about housing staff replacing or delivering those services, but about enabling them to work collaboratively to co-ordinate filling the vacuum through more effective collaborative leadership across communities. This necessity is brought out in a new report from the Chartered Institute of Housing and the Wheatley Group…

Housing staff expected to fill support gap, study finds

Housing professionals are increasingly expected to fill the gap left by the withdrawal of other services as tenants require increasing levels of support, a study has found. Read more >>>

The vacuum left by the reduction in services has been exacerbated by the impact of welfare reform and the CEO of Circle Housing is calling for greater collaborative working to solve the problems…

 

Circle Housing chief urges housing leaders to tackle welfare reform together

Circle Housing Chief Executive Mark Rogers has urged the housing industry, government and third sector agencies to pull together and support customers affected by welfare reform, in the light of new figures highlighting the challenges facing customers moving on to Universal Credit.  Read more >>>

However, shared service working in housing is occurring in small pockets with this example of co-ownership and sharing of training…

Housing associations join forces to buy training company

Three Midlands-based housing providers have joined forces to acquire an award-winning training company. Read more >>>


************
Local Government

I was running the CIPFA SS(PRAC)™ session on the SSA Trust & Vision toolbox yesterday. I asked the delegates, from local authorities, to name the things that a council would not want to share with another authority. Ultimately they agreed that everything is up for sharing from their view.

Yet only two years ago, with the same exercise there would have been three or four things at least. For example, Children’s Services, Adult Social Care, or Planning. It feels like the mind-set has shifted now and this can be seen in the rise of the ‘super council’ concept.

Super councils may only relate to economic development issues at the moment, but if successful with that service, the obvious question will arise, “Why aren’t we sharing other core services too?”…

North East ‘super council’ secures government backing

The Cabinet Office has begun the legal process to set up a new combined authority in the North East. Read more >>>

However, let’s not forget that the journey of collaborative working can be a bumpy one as partners change, or re-assess themselves and their future purpose…

Wirral shared services on hold

The Chief Executive of Wirral Council is to make a recommendation to pause the process of developing shared professional services with Cheshire West & Chester and Cheshire East Councils as it begins a major review of every service it provides. Read more >>>

************
Health

I admire the work of the King’s Fund in gnawing away at “wicked problems” that can only be solved through collaborative working. For you, the reality of the wicked problem in this report is that by 2030 you may be one of the ageing society whose pension is inadequate and you become dependent on integrated, state health care. So start working the solution now...!

King’s Fund: Ageing society demands a ‘fundamental shift’ in healthcare delivery

A fundamental shift is urgently needed in the delivery of health and care to meet the challenges of a rapidly ageing society, says a new report from The King’s Fund. Read more >>>

To finish this week, I nominate this article. Tracey Leforte who is responsible for procurement in the health service, provides helpful tips for working on collaborative procurement…

 

Soft skills crucial to stakeholder engagement, says procurement official

Utilising soft skills is crucial when dealing with stakeholders, the Deputy Director of Procurement at Barts Health NHS Trust has said. Read more >>>

News Summary of Collaboration and Shared Services from 5 March 2014



One of the harsh realities of shared services, is the elimination of duplication of effort  – a polite way of saying less people are likely to be in the new, better, lower-cost service. Colleague’s jobs will go in most cases.

Listening to a number of Cllrs in Wales with wards in high unemployment areas, they speak about the displacement of the shared service savings downstream by putting staff out of work on Friday through shared services, to have them walk into the Council offices on Monday to claim housing and other benefits.

They talk about the social and mental health costs of long-term unemployment, marital breakdown and other negative social outcomes. So when a key employment strategy of government has been to put public sector jobs in areas of high unemployment and then they implement projects that cut jobs, potentially the down-stream cost increase could begin if the Cllrs are right.

This seems to be where the unions are going in relation to the joint-venture (it is not a shared service as there was an ITT) between Steria and Cabinet Office called Shared Services Connected Ltd (SSCL). And the unions throw in the “off-shoring” debate too…

500 ex-civil service jobs 'to go', PCS union warns

Five hundred former civil servants across England and Wales are to be made redundant as their new employer shifts the work overseas, claims a union. Read more >>>

Talking of unions, this is the first time I have seen a public response from the Police Federation on shared service working. Usually it has been in-house…

 

Suffolk/Norfolk: Continued cutbacks could leave police at crisis point – warning

Suffolk’s Police Federation chairman Matt Gould made the comments in a statement with his Norfolk counterpart, Paul Ridgway, responding to shared services proposals designed to save the two counties’ forces a combined £4.3m. Read more >>>

Our  friends over at Collaborate have added to the wide number of reports on transforming services through collaborative working. You may want to use some of its materials to inform your arguments if you want to move beyond the alignment of the way things are done now and use your collaboration project as a way of transforming the service. (You would find our more practical Collaborative Leadership sessions helpful as well!)

 

Transform local services to tackle ‘huge pressure’ of rising demand

Councils must stem the mounting demand for services by finding a long-term answer to the challenges of austerity, a report claims. Read more >>>

************
Highway Code Updates

Now I know why so many local government people look puzzled when we do the Highway Code quiz session on G-Cloud and Data Protection. It feels like the government built the G-Cloud Market Place on the basis that “if you build it they will come”, and “they” haven’t turned up yet…

90% of local authorities yet to hear about G-Cloud

Tony Singleton, Director of G-Cloud says that G-Cloud has the potential to reach an estimated 30,000 buyers across the public sector. Read more >>>

VAT Exempt Cost Sharing Groups

HEFCE are pushing VAT Exempt Cost Sharing Groups and have produced an excellent on-line guide (114 pages) to help get this right - and I found a link to a HEFCE video from Sept 2013 too.

 If you find yourself at the centre of a collaboration project between VATable and non-VATable organisations then this will prove very useful. The online book is being regularly updated so you may want to store the link in your PC’s Highway Code folder, rather than download what could be a quickly out of date book…

VAT Cost Sharing Exemption HEFCE Guidance

This guidance sets the context of the cost sharing exemption for higher education. It allows existing providers of services to understand the issues which must be addressed to take advantage of the exemption, as well as identifying areas of service…Read more >>>

VAT Cost Sharing Exemption Video Guidance

In this (13 min) video, Steve Butcher, Head of Procurement and Shared Services at HEFCE, gives an overview of shared services in higher education, explains about the issue of VAT and previews new guidance from HEFCE on cost sharing exemption. Read more >>>

Legal Vehicles for Shared Services

In a forum on Linked-In a discussion has started on successful Mutuals, which you may like to join if you are working in that area. Most of you know my views. Organisations are only successful because of excellent leadership, management and culture. They are not excellent because they are called a Mutual, Ltd Co, CIC, LLP, etc. But if you join the debate you can have your say and prove me wrong…
A new discussion group has started on Linked-In to identify what makes Mutuals successful. If you are involved in that area of work you may like to join it by clicking here. You do have to be a Linked-In member to join the debate.

News Summary of Collaboration and Shared Services from 26 February 2014



Some news about ourselves to start with this week…

We are pleased to announce that Terry Huggins, former shared CEO of two local authorities and the 2011/12 president of SOLACE, has joined us to work on the Collaborative Leadership Programme and Shared Services Skills Programme.

Terry has uniquely been simultaneously the Chief Executive of two local authorities in different counties, without a shared boundary. He took South Holland District Council from a CPA rating of “satisfactory” to “excellent”.
Terry was an active member of the LGA cohort of Shared Chief Executives and is familiar with the differences and challenges of shared models. Terry will be leading on areas of Collaborative Leadership modelling and Shared Service Reviews.
We are also pleased to announce that SSA is collaborating with Chas Bradfield, Managing Director of Bradfield Solutions Ltd, on the development of our Collaborative Leadership and Shared Service Programme focusing on the Hampshire, M4 corridor and West of England areas.
Chas has a background as a public sector board level executive within local government where he worked as a Director and Deputy Chief Executive. He has led multi-million pound regeneration schemes, set up town centre management companies, and been instrumental in the development of business improvement districts.

Chas is also an Associate Lecturer with the Open University delivering the Postgraduate Certificate in Healthcare Leadership, the Mary Seacole Programme, part of the NHS Leadership Academy leadership development programme.
************
Collaborative Leadership

Carol Kinsey Goman, a US private sector guru in Collaborative Leadership, set out in Forbes Magazine, last week, eight key tips for Collaborative Leadership in the private sector. They are really no different from the many challenges in the public sector over here and worth reading. (You will need to skip past a Forbes advert to get to the article, but it is worth it…)

8 Tips For Collaborative Leadership

Today’s corporation exists in an increasingly complex and ever-shifting ocean of change. As a result, leaders need to rely more than ever on the intelligence and resourcefulness of their staff. Read more >>>

************
Local Government

Last week I suggested that you add this to the growing list of unitary discussions…

Report calls for six councils to be merged in Warwickshire

Plans to scrap six councils in Warwickshire and create a single unitary authority are to be debated in the county. Read more >>>

However, it is feels like there is a lack of collaborative leadership going on in Warwickshire as this article indicates that some people feel this is being done to them, rather than being done with them…

Warwick District Council refuses to join unitary status debate

Warwick District Council will not take part in any debate over proposals to scrap six councils in Warwickshire and create a single unitary authority. Read more >>>

Newton’s 3rd Law of Collaborative Leadership: If you get people grumpy about exploring a collaboration at outset, it’s much harder to get them involved later.

*********
Outsourcing

Capita have been picking up some good contracts recently and will be pleased with this one…

Capita chosen to deliver £325m shared network for Scotland's public sector

Nine-year deal to deliver the Scottish wide area network (SWAN). Outsourcing group Capita has been chosen to deliver a £325 million shared network project for the public sector in Scotland. Read more >>>

But maybe not so pleased  with Birmingham Council who want to cut the amount they pay Capita including an “…initiative is to ensure that the variable IT costs of the council fall as the number of staff is reduced through redundancies”. Do they mean it hasn’t been reduced whilst all those redundancies have been made over the last three years?....


Birmingham council reviews Capita outsourcing contract to find £20m savings

Birmingham City Council (BCC) is carrying out a review of its contract with outsourcing partner Capita to identify a further £20 million in savings. Read more >>>

 

When I read the news below, I went back through most of last year’s newsletters to see reports of who has been buying shared services from other councils. Couldn’t spot one, so I wonder if Essex CC have done their research around the phrase “…and use extra capacity to offer shared services to other public organisations in the UK.”…

 

Essex County Council Agrees Seven Year, £16.6m IT Deal With Fujitsu

Fujitsu has agreed a £16.6 million deal with the Essex County Council to overhaul its IT infrastructure, allowing it to be more cost effective and use extra capacity to offer shared services to other public organisations in the UK. Read more >>>

The market is full of organisations who want to sell, but the ones who want to buy are rare.